"How Important Are The Registers & Grills to the
Occupant?"
The Comfort Zone by Maury Tiernan, Geary Pacific Corp.
Whether in one of our factory built commercial buildings, or at home, the
occupant's contact with the HVAC system is usually limited to the thermostat
and the registers. They are really the only two items of the HVAC systems that
the occupants see and feel. So what's the big deal about registers and grills
any way? Just put in the cheapest ones available to keep the cost down. I hear
what your saying, but let's look at some issues.
The least expensive and previous most widely used supply register is a stamped
face, multi-louvered damper type. This is a carry over from the mobile home
industry. There are two reasons why this type of supply register will cause
unhappy occupants, and Service calls:
-
The face has it's "slots" stamped inward at 30 degrees from perpendicular. This
causes the air to blow almost straight down on the neck of the person below,
moving papers on the desk, and leaving hot cold spots in the room.
-
The damper is a multi-louver (not an opposed blade) damper. This is O.K. for
straight heating systems found in mobile homes and residences, but not for an
HVAC system. If the factory standard duct system is one size ductboard directly
off the Wall Mount, the only way to get equal air distribution to each register
is with OBD's (opposed blade damper). Ever had a complaint that the very first
room from the unit got no air at all, and the last room in the module got all
the air?
Whether your still using the "Modulux" type plank ceiling or a suspended T-Bar
type, the register you select makes a difference. More and more the end users
are requesting T-Bar type ceilings, which has motivated the Industry to look
for registers that have a face size of 24" x 24". This makes a lot of sense,
but your selection is still important. Generally, the most cost effective of
this style has a perforated face, and no damper of any kind. There are two
reasons why this supply register will cause problems for your end user:
-
When the air hits the perforated face, it forms a "pear shaped" air flow
pattern directly under it. This occurs no matter what type of directional
louvers are behind the perforation. An architect who specifies a $100 register
that has a perforated face is wasting the clients money. Once it hits the
perforation the air pattern is the same. A perforated register performs best in
a 16-20' high ceiling, not an 8' ceiling.
-
Dampers are not standard on any inexpensive perforated supply registers.
Because of this, dampers rarely get installed, and there is no way to control
the volume of air to each one.
THE ONLY PURPOSE OF A SUPPLY REGISTER IS TO MIX THE INCOMING CONDITIONED AIR
WITH THE AIR IN THE ROOM IN A QUIET AND DRAFTLESS METHOD.
It does not take an expensive supply register to do this. In fact, some
expensive $100 plus registers actually are very poor performers, and $15 ones
perform very well.
So here is the suggestion... use a curved blade supply register with either a
fixed or adjustable face blade. This will keep the air flow within 12" of the
ceiling, and gently mix the air without the occupant ever feeling a draft. The
fixed stamped curve blade works just as well as the adjustable curve blade and
at half the price. Both of these are available for "Modulux" or T-Bar type
ceilings.
Lastly use an OBD damper on the supply registers. This will allow you to
control where you want the air to go. Below are two brands and model numbers
for you to request that I know are very readily available in the western part
of the country, and probably in the East also. Just ask your HVAC supplier to
cross reference the brand and model in your area.
Airmate
# T604-0 12 x 12
for cut in type applications
Shoemaker
# 104-0 12 x 12-10
for 24 x 24 T-Bar applications
If you would like some submittal information with which to cross reference to an
available brand in your area, simply fax a request into the MBI Home Office and
the information will be forwarded to you.
|